Post by Devil Mingy on Jun 16, 2015 19:39:12 GMT -5
Okay, time to share my thoughts on the massive infodump of Halo we've received this last week.
Hunt The Truth
Escalation
Hunters in the Dark
Halo 5
First of all, E3 footage.
First of all, I think they picked a really bad level to demo. Not only is most of this demo just walking and sightseeing, but the few new features shown off aren't given any real gravitas because they aren't shown practically. The Artemis system should've been demonstrated to show flanking or a stealth route, not for two very obviously scripted sequences. Even the squad commands were so obviously choreographed that I wouldn't even know they were a feature if Game Informer hadn't told me; I'd just assume those events always happen that way. The final minutes do finally give us some shooting, as well as our first real look at the new Promethean Soldiers, presumably replacing the Knights as the standard troops while the Knights will now be used as a heavy unit. I think this'll fit it better, given the Knights' durability in Halo 4. We also hear the Promethean Soldiers speak english, presumably because the Didact didn't want them to and they just stopped caring (I'll never understand why 343i always takes the hard way when it comes to explaining minute details. Just say that the UNSC updated translation software). At the end, we also get to meet what I presume will be a prominent antagonist through Halo 5, the self-proclaimed Warden Eternal: Keeper of the Domain. All I can say is... wow, and I thought the Didact was hard to take seriously. On the other hand, it looks like he kicks Locke's ass, so good for him.
I still have the Game Informer stuff to go over, so I'm not done yet.
Hunt The Truth
I admit, I did not see that ending coming, and I loved it. ONI was devious, calculating, and one step ahead. That almost makes up for their abject stupidity to fail to get someone (or even an AI) to do a google search. Ben is probably one of the most sympathetic and tragic heroes in the series, and it's a testament to good writing that they did this without ever actually showing him. I wish some of Halo's other writers had this talent in them.
Nonetheless, I'm still curious why they decided to change the disclosure of the Spartan II program. While I certainly like that it is remaining classified (as disclosing gross human rights violations, especially on children, just to try to blame it all on one person and sweet everyone else's involvement under the rug is ludicrous), it brings to question what talked Osman out of doing it. Also, why do the Spartan IVs, even the lower new recruits, seem to be completely aware of such sensitive information and freely talk about it? If they didn't disclose Halsey's involvement in the Spartan-II program, then what is she known as a war criminal for? I suppose it's not the first retcon I'd ever have to deal with in the series.
And where does this leave Petra? She's definitely one of the more savvy characters in the fiction, but what kind of revenge is she hoping to get out of ONI? And what of FERO? Is she happy to see Ben be the sacrificial lamb, or is this a snag to her plan? What was her plan, anyway, besides mass chaos?
Nonetheless, I'm still curious why they decided to change the disclosure of the Spartan II program. While I certainly like that it is remaining classified (as disclosing gross human rights violations, especially on children, just to try to blame it all on one person and sweet everyone else's involvement under the rug is ludicrous), it brings to question what talked Osman out of doing it. Also, why do the Spartan IVs, even the lower new recruits, seem to be completely aware of such sensitive information and freely talk about it? If they didn't disclose Halsey's involvement in the Spartan-II program, then what is she known as a war criminal for? I suppose it's not the first retcon I'd ever have to deal with in the series.
And where does this leave Petra? She's definitely one of the more savvy characters in the fiction, but what kind of revenge is she hoping to get out of ONI? And what of FERO? Is she happy to see Ben be the sacrificial lamb, or is this a snag to her plan? What was her plan, anyway, besides mass chaos?
Escalation
The two recent issues are a character study of Lily Tanaka, future member of Locke's Fireteam Osiris. If there's one thing that I really love, it's short character studies. I think that is one of the great things you can do with shorter mediums such as novellas and comics, and Escalation hit it right out of the park with this one. Escalation has so far been a roller coaster of quality in terms of stories and characters. We've had the whole spectrum from Naiya Ray, a character that is everything Sarah Palmer should've been, to Daniel Clayton, a rebel binge drunk on revolutionary kool-aid and whose sole motivation is that he apparently had too good of a life with the UNSC. We've had quick and effective character stories like with Tanaka to the disjointed mess of 'The Next 72 Hours' that brought the Didact back as an even more farcical villain. The next issues of the series all the way up to Halo 5 will be about Absolute Record, where the Librarian told Halsey to go at the end of Spartan Ops. With Halsey and Mdama in control of both parts of the Janus Key now, I'm curious to see where they go with this, and ultimately if Absolute Record has anything to do with the Guardians or the Reclamation.
Hunters in the Dark
First of all, I want to thank my local Barnes and Noble for not giving a damn about street dates. I picked this up last week and speed read through it. I'm going back through it now to get a better idea on it and see if I missed anything, because this book felt very hollow. At its heart, I imagine it's supposed to be a character introduction to Olympia Vale, who proves that she's Spartan material by being lucky enough to not die. Overall, I never really got the feeling that she'd make a good soldier, let alone a Spartan, so I'm curious if there will be more about her in the future (or if we just have to fill in the blanks of character development ourselves like with Jul M'dama). Seeing N'tho and Usze return from their long absence to reprise their roles as players 3 and 4 was nice, too. I think Peter David might be one of my favorite writers as far as the Sangheili are concerned. He nailed them really well. As for the story itself, it followed all the points I expected it would, basically acting as a "Nightfall Done Right" story where two different cultures team up together on a blown to hell Forerunner world to stop a catastrophe and then escape before it's too late, all while fighting the installation's leftover machinations and their own animosities. Hunters in the Dark is far more focused and its characters far less stupid. In the end, they stop the not-quite-blown-up-enough Ark from activating all the rings and then they all pat themselves on the back and go home.
If there is one thing that really irked me all while I was reading it, it's Peter David's reliance on "as you know" exposition. It was bad when we had the top brass of ONI explaining the events at the end of Halo 3 to people who should absolutely know what happened, but it almost becomes comical when Vale has to explain Sangheili backstory to a Sangheili warrior. The non-dialogue exposition is equally problematic, often going on for paragraphs at a time and ruining the flow of a lot of certain scenes (Oh no, Solitude is unleashing the system's defenses on us... time for a 1 1/2 page explanation on Sentinels).
Overall, though, I did enjoy it. I'm hoping a second read through gives me some more insight, but I think it works very well as an introduction to Vale. If Initiation was half this good, Palmer might've been salvagable.
If there is one thing that really irked me all while I was reading it, it's Peter David's reliance on "as you know" exposition. It was bad when we had the top brass of ONI explaining the events at the end of Halo 3 to people who should absolutely know what happened, but it almost becomes comical when Vale has to explain Sangheili backstory to a Sangheili warrior. The non-dialogue exposition is equally problematic, often going on for paragraphs at a time and ruining the flow of a lot of certain scenes (Oh no, Solitude is unleashing the system's defenses on us... time for a 1 1/2 page explanation on Sentinels).
Overall, though, I did enjoy it. I'm hoping a second read through gives me some more insight, but I think it works very well as an introduction to Vale. If Initiation was half this good, Palmer might've been salvagable.
Halo 5
First of all, E3 footage.
First of all, I think they picked a really bad level to demo. Not only is most of this demo just walking and sightseeing, but the few new features shown off aren't given any real gravitas because they aren't shown practically. The Artemis system should've been demonstrated to show flanking or a stealth route, not for two very obviously scripted sequences. Even the squad commands were so obviously choreographed that I wouldn't even know they were a feature if Game Informer hadn't told me; I'd just assume those events always happen that way. The final minutes do finally give us some shooting, as well as our first real look at the new Promethean Soldiers, presumably replacing the Knights as the standard troops while the Knights will now be used as a heavy unit. I think this'll fit it better, given the Knights' durability in Halo 4. We also hear the Promethean Soldiers speak english, presumably because the Didact didn't want them to and they just stopped caring (I'll never understand why 343i always takes the hard way when it comes to explaining minute details. Just say that the UNSC updated translation software). At the end, we also get to meet what I presume will be a prominent antagonist through Halo 5, the self-proclaimed Warden Eternal: Keeper of the Domain. All I can say is... wow, and I thought the Didact was hard to take seriously. On the other hand, it looks like he kicks Locke's ass, so good for him.
I still have the Game Informer stuff to go over, so I'm not done yet.








HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!! Oh wow, what the hell am I looking at? What joke do I make? Do I go for the Dr. Nefarious from Ratchet and Clank joke or the Dry Bones from Mario joke? How about the double-bladed hard-light sword? I'm sorry, but there's nothing about this design that I can take seriously. 

